Skip to main content

Schilling and Gray : close - but no cigar

Gray's telephone caveatThe Russian born Baron Pavel Schilling is one of the forgotten pioneers of the telegraph. He had developed a working needle telegraph four years before Cooke and Wheatstone - and a working code seven years before Morse.

But Schilling's work in Germany was halted by the government there in 1836 and soon afterwards he died. He had the right idea but in the wrong place and at the wrong time - a little like Elisha Gray.

Gray was the 'nearly' man of the telephone - being out of the running by a couple of hours and one word. The hours were those that separated his visit to the patent office with that of the Bell patent filed by Gardiner Hubbard. The word was 'caveat' which was what Gray called his application. It didn't have quite the same status as a full patent application, which was what Hubbard had just filed for Bell.

Gray's prototype was better and his technology superior to Bell's in many ways. But he wasn't as ready to gamble as Bell and Hubbard - and in the end that was to make the difference.